The semiconductor supply chain faces a persistent paradox: a severe shortage of people, while many companies lack the time or budget to invest in training. Rutger Holtzer describes what companies need right now, and why structural talent development only works if the sector tackles it together.
By Rutger Holtzer, ChipNL Competence Centre
Talk to manufacturing companies in the chain and you always hear the same story. Everyone needs staff at the same time, or, during a contraction, collectively wants to let part of their people go. That is partly a matter of the business cycle, but it also points to something more structural: this is a cost-driven sector with a short horizon for talent.
“The talent pool does not grow by recruiting harder, but by feeding it together.”
Apart from this, the semiconductor industry is not a homogeneous sector with a single labour market story, but a chain that cuts across sectors, from metalworking and precision mechanics to chip design and system integration. Each of those links has a different time horizon, a different cycle and often a different view of what “talent” actually means. What most companies do have in common: there is no time for anything that is not urgent.
What do companies need?
Willingness is not the problem, ability is
In equipment manufacturing, the conversation about talent is in practice almost always about the short term: how do we bring in enough people quickly, in a sector that is cost-driven and where production pressure leaves little room for anything else. That is not short-sightedness, but a rational response to the circumstances in which many companies operate. A considerable part of the chain consists of SMEs without a strong HR function, let alone a strategic training department. For them, “looking at talent differently” is not a question of willingness but of ability: the capacity to invest structurally is often simply missing.
What already works
That does not mean no concrete steps are being taken that are feasible, also for smaller players. Partners are working together on one shared overview of vacancies, updated every quarter, so that young people and career switchers do not depend on chance contacts to find a place. This also matters for other partners in the ecosystem, such as labour market regions and work centres, educational institutions and private training providers. Precisely because we need to look at talent differently, which companies are not used to, interventions are necessary. Younger generations are not keeping pace with the ageing workforce. With young people alone we cannot even meet the replacement demand of retirees, let alone absorb a sector growth of 26,000 people (national strengthening plan for microchip talent). To let non-traditional target groups enter early, data and pilots are needed, such as for wire EDM operators, career-switch programmes for CNC operators, workplace coaching and traineeships for MBO (secondary vocational) students in SMEs.
Making outflow predictable
In addition, together with consortia of schools, work centres and others, we visit companies and actively ask them for their five-year forecast of outflow through retirement, so that the loss of experience becomes predictable instead of a surprise. Career switching and retraining gain a firmer foundation as companies commit to a ‘career-switch profile’, in which the newcomer can add value after three months of training and actually fill a vacancy. Industry and training providers are also already jointly supplying hybrid teachers and structural coaching, so that practical knowledge reaches education without individual companies having to arrange this on their own.
“Younger generations are not keeping pace with the ageing workforce.”
Education becomes demand-driven
Collaboration between education and industry is getting under way. One reason is that Lifelong Learning (LLO) education is increasingly demand-driven and modular.
If you do what you always did, you get what you always got
Beneath that acute shortage lies a more persistent pattern: the sector usually treats talent as something you acquire somewhere, rather than something you build together over a longer period. That is not an accidental error of thinking, but the result of three mechanisms that reinforce each other.
1. Keeping knowledge within your own walls
The first mechanism is that companies have traditionally been used to training their people as individual parties and keeping knowledge within the company. This stems from competitive sensitivity, which is more specific than just the fear of a competitor poaching someone. It is also about concerns over intellectual property: whoever invests in training people with access to process and product knowledge runs the risk of seeing that knowledge return at a competitor through staff turnover. As long as there are no sector-wide agreements on this, closedness remains the rational choice for individual companies, even though that choice is costly for the sector as a whole. On top of that, there is the adage “We are so specific, you cannot learn this anywhere else”.
From my own role in training and development, I constantly see that tension: almost every company endorses that employees are its most important capital, but as soon as it comes to sharing training capacity or knowledge, the instinctive protection of the company's own (short-term) interest wins over the collective logic.
2. Whoever invests alone takes a risk
The second mechanism is a classic collective action problem. If a company does not invest while the sector does not either, everyone loses: high costs, scarce talent. If a company does invest while others do not, it runs the risk of competitors benefiting without contributing themselves. Only when companies invest jointly and with binding agreements does a bigger pool emerge in which everyone wins. Without such agreements, individual restraint is not a failure but the predictable outcome of the game.
3. The business cycle trap
The third mechanism is the business cycle trap, and it reinforces the first two. In an upturn there is no time, because all focus is on achieving output. In a downturn there is no budget. As soon as recovery sets in, the pattern repeats, with the same shortage as a result. Talent development thus structurally becomes the last item on the budget, precisely at the moments when it would have the most effect: investing during a dip is exactly when the next cycle is prepared.
Together, these three mechanisms explain why good intentions rarely lead to structural change. The problem does not lie in the will of individual companies, but in a system in which the rational choice at company level systematically produces a suboptimal outcome at sector level.
“If we change nothing, we will keep circulating people, drive up salaries and the sector will lose out to other sectors in the Netherlands.”
What we can do now
In the medium term, we need to make agreements on long-term investment in a gentlemen's agreement. In the short term, we can take actions that set change in motion. Offer students perspective with internships and entry-level positions, good coaching and a path to progress. Work on strategic workforce planning that brings outflow through retirement into view. Deploy some of the people in the autumn of their careers to coach young people and career switchers. Now that the AI boom is doing the sector no harm, you can use the financial room to train people now, but also to set up a system or fund that can soften the loss of knowledge in the next downturn.
If we change nothing, we will keep circulating people, drive up salaries and the sector will lose out to other sectors in the Netherlands.
Breaking the trend together
The talent pool does not grow by recruiting harder, but by feeding it together. This calls for instruments that go beyond good intentions. One of the most concrete instruments is a sectoral training fund, which deliberately decouples training from the business cycle.
Not as a non-binding intention, but with the aim of arriving at a collective norm that education, training providers and industry carry together, and that should turn the narrative from “you find talent” to “you develop talent” as a shared conviction throughout the chain.
The role of ChipNL CC
ChipNL Competence Centre actively contributes to this, among other things through talent programmes and by connecting companies, education and government around these questions. That connecting role is needed to move from separate initiatives to a structural approach: not waiting for the next shortage to arise, but building now a sector in which development is a matter of course, in every economic climate, instead of something you only take up when it suits you.
About the author
Rutger Holtzer is Program Lead Talent Semicon at Brainport Development, a partner in ChipNL CC.
ChipNL Competence Centre (ChipNL CC) is the Dutch Chips Competence Centre under the EU Chips Act and helps startups, SMEs and knowledge institutions with talent development and skills. Read more about our support for Talent & Skills.
Want to know how demand for talent is developing? Read our analysis of semiconductor vacancies in Q3 2026 or download the factsheets: